PASCA PRK TENANG

Tenang vote: Winners and losers UPDATED @ 10:31:25 PM 30-01-2011 January 30, 2011 MCA’s inability to dominate on its president’s home ground has caused murmurs within Umno. — file pic ANALYSIS, Jan 30 — It was not quite the 5,000-vote majority the Barisan Nasional (BN) and Datuk Seri Najib Razak craved, but the margin of victory was still convincing. Here are some of the winners and losers from today’s results: LOSERS Pakatan Rakyat (PR) PR were still unable to make significant inroads into Barisan Nasional’s (BN) Johor fortress. Its candidate was on the defensive throughout the campaign, and failed to set the tone of the contest. There also appeared to be no unified message for voters except to appeal to their sense of outrage at any perceived unhappiness with BN. PR’s campaign was ultimately long on rhetoric and short on substantive issues. 1 Malaysia BN’s campaign was still a classic case of divide and rule. MCA attacked PAS’s Islamist image and chastised the DAP for allegedly opening the door for an eventual Islamic state, to appeal to Chinese fears. Umno, on the other hand, called its rivals PAS a stooge of the “communist-inspired” DAP and a sell-out of Malay rights. Ultimately, the more rural communities in Tenang accepted the message. WINNER Umno The party’s machinery worked well, and there was little sign of the divisions seen in previous campaigns. Umno appeared to be more united than ever and look to be in a strong position ahead of the rumoured general election. But this was, after all, Umno’s fortress. It utilised its home ground advantage by denying PAS and PR a chance to even spread its message. It started campaigning early on, and by the time PAS set up shop, it was already too late. Many of the Malay voters in the constituency were also Umno members. JURY OUT ON MCA The MCA will certainly claim it has now turned around its fortunes after receiving more Chinese votes this time when compared to Election 2008. But this was Datuk Seri Dr Chua Soi Lek’s home turf, and the margin of Chinese votes obtained by MCA was still less than convincing. It remains clear that MCA continues to ride on Umno, with many in the BN lynchpin beginning to feel resentment towards their partners for their inability to convincingly win over the support of the Chinese, especially since this was the MCA president’s home ground. PAS PAS has shown that it is still unable to extend its influence on Malay voters beyond its traditional strongholds. Umno's hold on the Malay ground remains firm, and if the Tenang vote is taken as an indicator the BN party has regained some of the votes it lost in 2008. On the other hand, PAS's drift in deciding where it stands on the Islamic state is starting to becoming a drag on PR.